Cross-Border Tax

Transfer Pricing Basics: How Should Related-Party Transactions Be Priced?

Chinese tax authorities assess whether related-party pricing complies with the arm's length principle under Article 41 of the Enterprise Income Tax Law. Whether your pricing holds up depends on two things: choosing the right pricing method, and preparing complete contemporaneous documentation. This page breaks down five checkpoints, with specific regulatory references and monetary thresholds.


Checkpoints

Five checkpoints, from qualification to response

Compliance does not hinge on whether the price is "low" — it hinges on whether you can demonstrate that the price is comparable to what unrelated parties would agree on.

EIT Law Art. 41 — Arm's length principle Art. 48 — Special tax adjustment SAT Announcement No. 42 (2016) SAT Announcement No. 64 (2016) SAT Announcement No. 24 (2021)

01    Related-party determination

A 25% shareholding is only one of seven tests — licensing dependence, cash pooling and personnel appointment also create related-party relationships.

02    Arm's length principle

More than a price comparison: comparable parties, arm's length price and ordinary course of business — three layers that must all hold.

03    Method selection

Five reasonable methods, selected in a fallback order based on comparability.

04    Contemporaneous documentation

Three tiers of documentation, four monetary thresholds and multiple deadlines.

05    Responding to an audit

Adjustments carry surcharge interest — whether documentation was provided decides a 5-percentage-point spread.


Related Party

Is it a related party? 25% is only one of the lines

Article 109 of the EIT Law Implementation Regulations sets out the principle; SAT Announcement No. 42 (2016), Article 2, lists seven situations:

1    A party directly or indirectly holds 25% or more of another; both are directly or indirectly held 25%+ by a third party

2    Holding below 25%, but inter-company borrowing amounts to 50%+ of either party's paid-in capital, or 10%+ of one party's total borrowing is guaranteed by the other

3    Holding below 25%, but one party's operations depend on patents, non-patented technology, trademarks or copyrights licensed by the other

4    Holding below 25%, but one party's purchasing, sales or service activities are controlled by the other

5    More than half of one party's directors or senior officers are appointed by the other, or concurrently serve as the other's directors or officers

6    Two individuals related by marriage, direct bloodline or sibling ties (and other support relationships) each hold the relationships above with both parties

7    Other common interests in substance

The most common misjudgment: looking only at equity

Tests 2 through 5 have nothing to do with shareholding. A Chinese subsidiary using the overseas parent's ERP system, brand licensing and technology licenses falls under Test 3 even with a simple ownership structure.

Typical mappings

Group cash pooling maps to Test 2; the headquarters seconding a finance director maps to Test 5. For indirect shareholding, a 25%+ stake in the intermediary counts the intermediary's stake in the target; stakes held jointly by related individuals are aggregated.


Arm's Length

More than a price: the three layers

Article 110 of the Implementation Regulations: the principle that unrelated parties transact at fair prices and in the ordinary course of business. In practice it is often compressed to one layer.

Layer 1    Compare against transactions between unrelated parties

Comparables must be transactions between independent enterprises — never another related-party deal inside the group.

Layer 2    Compare the transaction price itself

The focus is the price, not merely the final margin — inflated costs or allocated expenses can make margins look healthy.

Layer 3    Compare the ordinary course of business

Terms, payment cycles, credit periods, risk bearing and after-sales service must be within a comparable range. 180-day credit for a related party versus 60 days for independent customers is itself part of the price.


Methods

Five methods — in what order should they be chosen?

Article 111 of the Implementation Regulations lists five reasonable methods plus a fallback clause.

MethodCore logicTypical scenarios
Comparable Uncontrolled Price (CUP)Price based on identical or similar transactions between unrelated partiesHighly comparable open-market transactions available
Resale PriceResale price to unrelated parties less an appropriate gross margin for similar activitiesDistributors, trading operations
Cost PlusCosts plus a reasonable markup for expenses and profitManufacturing, processing, service provision
Transactional Net Margin Method (TNMM)Net profit level determined by reference to comparable unrelated transactionsWeak product comparability, relatively simple functions
Profit SplitCombined profits or losses allocated between the parties by reasonable standardsSignificant intangibles, high group synergy


Selection order

Comparable prices (internal comparables first, then external open-market data) → gross-margin level (Resale Price, Cost Plus) → net-profit level (TNMM). TNMM is the most used method in Chinese practice — not because it is the first choice, but because product-level comparables are hard to find.


Documentation

Three tiers of documentation, four thresholds

Article 43 of the EIT Law requires an annual related-party transactions reporting form with the annual CIT filing; the detailed requirements sit in SAT Announcement No. 42 (2016), Articles 10–13. The bars below show the relative scale of the four local-file thresholds.

RMB 1 bn    Master file: total related-party transactions exceed RMB 1 billion; or cross-border related transactions occur and the group has prepared a master file

RMB 200 m    Local file: transfers of tangible asset ownership (processing business measured by annual import/export customs value)

RMB 100 m    Local file: transfers of financial assets

RMB 100 m    Local file: transfers of intangible asset ownership

RMB 40 m    Local file: aggregate of other related-party transactions

Special-issue documentation

Required for cost contribution arrangements entered into or performed, and for thin-capitalisation cases where the related-party debt-to-equity ratio exceeds the standard ratio and arm's length compliance must be justified.

Two exemptions

Enterprises transacting only with domestic related parties need not prepare the three tiers; parties to an advance pricing arrangement (APA) need not prepare local and special-issue documentation for transactions covered by the APA, and those amounts are excluded from threshold calculations.

Within 12 months    Master file: prepared within 12 months after the fiscal year end of the group's ultimate holding enterprise

By June 30    Local and special-issue documentation: prepared before June 30 of the year following the transaction year

Within 30 days    Submit within 30 days of the tax authority's request

Keep 10 years    Retain for 10 years from the date of completion

Easy to miss: losses still require local files

Enterprises performing single-function manufacturing (processing trade) or distribution and contract R&D for overseas related parties should in principle maintain a reasonable profit level. If a loss occurs, a local file must be prepared for the loss year regardless of thresholds. This targets contract manufacturers with persistent thin margins or losses — it looks at function and outcome, not amount.

Common trigger scenarios

A Chinese subsidiary paying technology royalties to its overseas parent, or procuring materials from fellow group companies at prices set by headquarters — when a special tax investigation opens years later and no comparables or pricing rationale can be produced, that is the classic risk scenario.


Cost of Gaps

The direct economic value of documentation

Where the tax authority makes an adjustment requiring supplementary tax payment, interest is levied at the PBOC benchmark RMB lending rate for the corresponding period plus 5 percentage points (Article 121 of the Implementation Regulations).

However, where the enterprise provides contemporaneous documentation and related materials as required, interest is levied at the benchmark rate only. An adjustment spanning three tax years already involves substantial tax — the 5-point spread is rarely a small number.


Response

If an investigation opens, three moves to make

1    Catch up on documentation

Even after the deadline, voluntary submission still influences the interest treatment and the assessment of cooperation. Missing and outdated documentation are two different states requiring different handling.

2    Build a robust benchmarking analysis

Explain the screening logic for comparables (industry, scale, functions, years) and why those years were chosen; present results as a range. Tax authorities accept ranges — not a two-decimal "standard answer".

3    Consider an APA

Under SAT Announcement No. 64 (2016), APAs proceed through six stages — pre-filing meeting, intent, analysis, formal application, negotiation and signing, monitoring — in unilateral, bilateral or multilateral forms. Announcement No. 24 (2021) introduced a simplified procedure for unilateral APAs. It converts after-the-fact investigation into before-the-fact certainty — a cost-controllable option for enterprises with large, stable related-party transactions.


Services

CMAP's transfer pricing compliance support

End-to-end transfer pricing support for foreign-invested enterprises and cross-border business teams in China:

Related-party transaction mapping & determination;Comparability analysis & method selection;Master file & local file preparation;APA application support;Special tax investigation response

Back to Articles